Serger vs Sewing Machine: Do You Need Both?

We research products independently. When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from Amazon at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Learn more.

The short verdict: buy a sewing machine first. Add a serger when you start sewing knits regularly or want store-bought-looking seams. A sewing machine does every essential job: seams anywhere on the fabric, zippers, buttonholes, topstitching, hems and quilting. A serger does one job brilliantly. It trims, sews and finishes the edge of a seam in a single fast pass, and it's the best tool there is for stretchy knits.

In the serger vs sewing machine question, they aren't really competitors. Most people who sew garments seriously end up owning both, but the sewing machine always comes first.

What Is a Serger?

A serger (the American name for an overlock machine) is a specialized edge-finishing machine. Instead of a bobbin, it uses one or two needles plus two loopers that wrap thread around the raw edge of the fabric, while a built-in knife trims the seam allowance just ahead of the needles. The result is the neat, thread-wrapped seam you see inside almost every T-shirt you own.

Because the looped stitch has built-in give, a serger seam stretches with knit fabric instead of snapping. That's its big advantage.

Serger vs Sewing Machine: Side-by-Side

The speeds come from current beginner models: for example, Brother lists 750 spm for the CS7000X and SINGER lists 1,100 spm for its Heavy Duty 4452, while sergers like the Brother 1034D and JUKI MO-654DE are rated at 1,300 and 1,500 spm.

The Differences, One by One

1. How the stitch is formed

A sewing machine makes a lockstitch: the needle thread and the bobbin thread interlock inside the fabric. It's strong, flat and the same on both sides, which is why it's used for topstitching and visible seams.

A serger makes an overlock stitch: the needle threads go through the fabric while the upper and lower loopers carry thread over and around the edge. There's no bobbin. The stitch is bulkier but stretchier, and it fully encases the raw edge.

2. Trimming the edge

A serger's knife cuts the seam allowance as you sew, so the seam is sewn, trimmed and finished in one go. A sewing machine leaves the raw edge as it is. To finish it, you need a second pass with a zigzag or overcast stitch, or pinking shears.

3. Where it can sew

This is the biggest practical difference. A serger only works at the fabric's edge. A sewing machine can sew anywhere: a dart in the middle of a panel, a pocket on a shirt front, a zipper, a buttonhole, a quilt block, a line of topstitching. That's why a serger can't replace a sewing machine.

4. Knits and stretch fabrics

Sergers are the better tool for jersey, rib knit, spandex and fleece. Their stitch stretches, and differential feed (two sets of feed dogs moving at adjustable speeds) prevents the wavy, stretched-out seams that knits get on a regular machine. A sewing machine can sew knits with a ball point needle, a stretch stitch and often a walking foot, but it takes more care.

5. Speed

Sergers are fast. Many run at 1,300 to 1,500 spm and handle three jobs in one pass. On a T-shirt or pair of leggings, that's a big time saver. Sewing machines are slower but more precise for detailed work.

6. Threading and setup

A sewing machine threads in a minute: spool, tension, take-up lever, needle, plus a bobbin. A serger has three to five thread paths, and the loopers must be threaded in a specific order. Threading is the steepest part of the serger learning curve. Newer models help with color-coded paths, looper threading aids and, on premium machines like the Brother AIR1800 and JUKI MO-1000, air threading.

7. Thread and needles

Sergers usually run from cones, and a 4-thread stitch needs four of them. Many home sergers use standard household needles (JUKI lists HAx1 needles for its MO-654DE), but always check your manual. A sewing machine uses one spool and a bobbin.

8. Cost

Beginner sergers generally start in a similar price tier to mid-range beginner sewing machines and climb steeply for air threading or 5-thread models. Since you need a sewing machine regardless, a serger is an added cost, not a substitute.

Which Machine for Which Project?

Here's how the work splits on projects beginners commonly make. "Either" means a sewing machine does the job fine and a serger just speeds up the seam finishing.

The pattern is clear: if a project involves knit fabric, a serger saves real time. If it involves zippers, buttons, topstitching or quilting, the sewing machine does the important work.

What About a Coverstitch Machine?

A coverstitch machine is a third type. It sews the parallel rows of stitching on the hems of T-shirts and leggings, with a chain stitch on the back. It doesn't trim. Some combination machines do both overlock and coverstitch, but beginners rarely need one. Brother's 2340CV is an example of a dedicated coverstitch machine (2-, 3- and 4-thread cover stitch plus chain stitch).

Can a Sewing Machine Do the Serger's Job?

Mostly, yes, just more slowly. Here's how to get close:

1. Use an overcast stitch with an overcasting foot. Many beginner machines include this foot; the Brother CS7000X does, for example. The foot has a small bar that keeps the stitch wrapped over the edge.
2. Use a zigzag stitch about 1/8" from the raw edge, then trim close to the stitching.
3. Sew knits with a stretch stitch (or a narrow zigzag) and a ball point needle.
4. Try French seams on light wovens: the raw edge is enclosed inside the seam, no serger needed.
5. Use pinking shears on stable woven seams that won't be washed often.

If you're doing all five regularly and wishing you had more time, that's the sign it's time for a serger. Our presser feet guide explains the overcasting foot.

Choose a Sewing Machine If…

• You're just starting to sew. A sewing machine is the essential tool.
• You'll sew woven cotton, linen, denim, quilts, bags or home décor.
• You need zippers, buttonholes, pockets, topstitching or quilting.
• You want one machine that does almost everything.

Start with our best sewing machines for beginners, then learn the basics in our guide to how to use a sewing machine.

Choose a Serger (as Your Second Machine) If…

• You sew T-shirts, leggings, activewear or other knits often.
• You want clean, professional seam finishes inside your garments.
• You make lots of napkins, scarves or ruffles and want rolled hems.
• You're spending a lot of time finishing seams on your sewing machine.

Our best sergers for beginners compares seven models, from budget picks to air-threading machines.

How Most Sewers Use Both Together

On a typical knit T-shirt, the two machines split the work:

1. Serger: sew the shoulder seams, attach the sleeves, close the side seams. Each is sewn, trimmed and finished in one pass.
2. Sewing machine: attach a neckband with a stretch stitch if you want more control, topstitch it, and sew the hems with a twin needle (or use a coverstitch machine).
3. Sewing machine: add any labels, pockets or decorative stitching.

On a woven garment like a button-up shirt, it's the reverse. The sewing machine does almost everything, and the serger just finishes the raw edges of the seams.

Common Mistakes When Choosing

• Buying a serger as your only machine. You'll soon hit a zipper or buttonhole it can't sew.
• Paying for 5 threads you won't use. A 3/4-thread serger covers knits and edge finishing for most beginners.
• Ignoring threading help. If looper threading frustrates you, you'll avoid the machine. Color-coded paths are the minimum; looper aids or air threading are worth paying for if you're anxious about it.
• Expecting a serger to sew seams away from the edge. It can't; the knife and loopers work at the edge only.

FAQ